LoyaltyLion vs Mage Loyalty: Features, Pricing and Shopify Loyalty Compared

The choice between LoyaltyLion and Mage Loyalty comes down to analytics or value. LoyaltyLion suits established brands that need advanced retention analytics, Klaviyo automation and multilingual programmes. It has a free plan for up to 400 orders a month, and paid plans start at $199/month. Mage Loyalty suits growing Shopify stores and includes VIP tiers, Shopify POS and wishlists from $49/month.

Loyaltylion vs mage loyalty

Choosing between LoyaltyLion and Mage Loyalty comes down to more than points and rewards. Both platforms help Shopify merchants build customer loyalty programmes, encourage repeat purchases and improve retention. However, they differ in pricing structures, customisation, customer experiences and how merchants manage their loyalty programmes.

LoyaltyLion focuses on loyalty analytics, customer segmentation, referrals and retention optimisation. Mage Loyalty takes a Shopify-focused approach, combining loyalty programmes with VIP tiers, referrals, wishlists and customer account experiences.

This comparison examines their features, pricing, integrations and practical use cases to help Shopify businesses choose the right platform.

LoyaltyLion vs Mage Loyalty: At a Glance

Comparison Factor LoyaltyLion Mage Loyalty
Platform Shopify and other ecommerce platforms Shopify-focused
Points and rewards Yes Yes
VIP tiers Advanced plan or add-on Starter and above
Referral programmes Yes Yes
Store credit Yes Yes
Cashback rewards Not a core listed feature Growth plan
Wishlist Not a native core feature Yes
Customer accounts Loyalty page integration Extended account experiences
Shopify POS Yes Yes
Checkout extensions Shopify Plus checkout redemption Growth plan
Loyalty analytics Advanced retention and revenue insights Basic to advanced analytics
Email marketing integrations Klaviyo and other integrations Klaviyo, Omnisend and others
Customisation Branded loyalty page and custom rules No-code customisation and Shopify-focused experiences
Free plan Yes, up to 400 monthly orders No
Starting paid price $199/month for Classic $15/month for Essential

LoyaltyLion vs Mage Loyalty: Feature Comparison

Both platforms support the fundamentals of customer loyalty. However, their differences become more noticeable when merchants look at how customers interact with the store beyond earning and redeeming points.

Points and rewards

LoyaltyLion offers a structured points-based system that allows customers to earn rewards through purchases and other engagement activities. Merchants can create custom earning rules and offer discounts, gifts and other incentives.

Mage Loyalty also supports points and rewards, with additional options such as store credit and cashback on eligible plans. Merchants can use different reward types to encourage customers to return and complete future purchases.

VIP tiers and customer engagement

LoyaltyLion supports VIP tiers through its Advanced and Plus plans, with an optional VIP add-on available on Classic. Merchants can create different customer levels based on spending or points accumulation and offer benefits to encourage continued engagement.

Mage Loyalty includes VIP tiers in its Starter plan and above. Businesses can create loyalty levels and provide customers with tier-based rewards and incentives.

Referral programmes

Both platforms allow merchants to use referrals to attract new customers through existing customer relationships.

LoyaltyLion supports referral rewards as part of its loyalty offering, helping brands encourage recommendations and customer acquisition.

Mage Loyalty also offers referral campaigns, with additional event tracking and advanced referral capabilities available on its Growth plan.

Wishlist and save-for-later functionality

One noticeable difference between the platforms is wishlist functionality.

LoyaltyLion primarily focuses on loyalty programmes, rewards and retention analytics. Merchants looking for a dedicated wishlist experience may need to integrate another application.

Mage Loyalty includes wishlist and save-for-later functionality. Customers can save products they are interested in and revisit them when they are ready to purchase.

For fashion, beauty and lifestyle stores, this can be useful because shoppers often browse several products before making a purchase.

Analytics and reporting

LoyaltyLion places considerable emphasis on analytics and loyalty performance. Merchants can monitor retention, customer lifetime value, referrals and revenue attributed to loyalty activities. Its Plus plan also includes AI-recommended campaigns and rewards.

Mage Loyalty offers loyalty analytics and reporting, with more advanced reporting available on Growth. Its approach connects loyalty activities with the wider Shopify retention experience.

Shopify POS and checkout experience

For merchants operating both online and physical stores, connecting loyalty programmes across sales channels is important.

LoyaltyLion supports Shopify POS, with single-location support on Classic and multiple-location capabilities on higher plans. Its points redemption at checkout is available through Shopify Plus checkout extensions.

Mage Loyalty includes Shopify POS integration from Starter. Its Growth plan adds checkout extensions, allowing merchants to bring loyalty redemption closer to the checkout process.

LoyaltyLion vs Mage Loyalty: Pricing Comparison

Pricing is an important consideration when selecting a loyalty application, particularly for growing Shopify stores. The two platforms follow different pricing structures and package their features differently.

LoyaltyLion pricing

LoyaltyLion offers a free plan for smaller stores and three primary paid tiers: Classic, Advanced and Plus.
Plan Price Included Orders
Free $0 Up to 400/month
Classic $199/month 500/month
Advanced Custom Based on order volume
Plus Custom Based on order volume

What do the plans include?

  • Free: Basic points earning, discount rewards, branding, loyalty analytics and customer segmentation.
  • Classic: Branded loyalty page, customisable earning rules, integrations, onboarding support and Klaviyo email flows.
  • Advanced: VIP tiers, product-page points, enhanced Shopify POS and multilingual translations.
  • Plus: AI-recommended rewards, advanced Klaviyo events, automated loyalty flows and strategic optimisation support.

LoyaltyLion also provides a 14-day free trial for paid plans. Its pricing is linked to monthly order volume, and Advanced and Plus require a custom quote.

Mage Loyalty pricing

Mage Loyalty offers three published paid plans and a tailored Enterprise option.

Plan Monthly Price Included Monthly Orders
Essential $15 500
Starter $49 500
Growth $499 2,500
Enterprise Custom Custom

What do the plans include?

  • Essential: Points, rewards, referral programmes, loyalty widgets, loyalty emails, branding and basic analytics. It includes two integrations.
  • Starter: Adds a dedicated loyalty page, Shopify POS, VIP tiers, tiered rewards, referral campaigns and advanced integrations.
  • Growth: Adds checkout extensions, store credit, cashback, advanced referrals, custom integrations, Klaviyo events and advanced analytics.
  • Enterprise: Tailored capabilities and pricing for larger businesses.

Essential and Starter charge an additional $0.20 per order above their 500-order allowance. The published Growth plan includes 2,500 monthly orders. Mage also offers a seven-day free trial.

Which platform offers better pricing?

Mage Loyalty has a lower starting paid price, making it accessible to businesses that want more than a basic free loyalty programme.

LoyaltyLion offers a free entry point, which is useful for smaller stores testing loyalty programmes. However, its Classic plan starts at $199 per month, and businesses requiring VIP tiers, enhanced POS functionality or advanced automation may need to consider higher plans or add-ons.

Mage’s $49 Starter plan includes VIP tiers and Shopify POS, giving growing merchants a more affordable entry point for these capabilities.

The important consideration is not just the starting price. Businesses should compare monthly order allowances, integration requirements, additional modules and the actual features needed for their retention strategy.

Integrations and Shopify Compatibility

Integrations determine how easily a loyalty programme fits into a store’s existing marketing and ecommerce operations.

Both platforms support integrations with popular ecommerce tools. However, the available integrations and their access can depend on the selected plan.

LoyaltyLion highlights its wider integration ecosystem, including more than 100 ecommerce tools. Mage focuses on connecting Shopify merchants with email marketing, reviews, subscriptions, returns and customer support applications.

Pros and Cons of LoyaltyLion vs Mage Loyalty

LoyaltyLion

Pros

  • Established loyalty platform with a long track record.
  • Detailed loyalty analytics and retention reporting.
  • Customisable points, rewards and earning rules.
  • Integrations with a broad range of ecommerce applications.
  • Multilingual loyalty experiences on eligible plans.
  • Dedicated onboarding and strategic support options.

Cons

  • Paid plans start at $199 per month.
  • Advanced and Plus pricing requires a custom quote.
  • VIP tiers are not included in the basic free plan.
  • Some advanced capabilities require higher plans or paid add-ons.
  • Wishlist functionality may require an additional application.
  • Advanced campaign automation and AI recommendations are restricted to Plus.

Mage Loyalty

Pros

  • Affordable Essential and Starter entry plans.
  • VIP tiers and Shopify POS included from Starter.
  • Wishlist and save-for-later functionality.
  • Points, referrals, rewards and store credit in one platform.
  • Checkout extensions on Growth.
  • Integrations with popular Shopify applications.
  • Advanced customisation and reporting options.

Cons

  • Shopify-focused rather than a multi-platform solution.
  • No permanent free plan.
  • Essential and Starter have additional per-order charges above their included limits.
  • Advanced checkout and cashback features require Growth.
  • Its Shopify App Store review history is considerably smaller than LoyaltyLion’s.

Retenzy: An All-in-One Alternative for Shopify Loyalty, Referrals and Reviews

For Shopify merchants who would rather not pay for separate loyalty, referral and review apps, Retenzy’s all-in-one customer retention platform brings these tools together. Brands can reward repeat purchases with flexible loyalty points and offer exclusive perks through tiered VIP memberships to their highest-value customers. A built-in refer-a-friend programme that brings in new shoppers turns loyal customers into advocates, while automated review requests after every order build social proof on product pages. For growing stores, this means one connected retention setup and fewer standalone apps to manage, which keeps the customer experience consistent from first order to repeat purchase.

Final Verdict

LoyaltyLion and Mage Loyalty approach customer retention from different perspectives. LoyaltyLion is an established loyalty platform with a strong emphasis on analytics, customer segmentation, integrations and campaign optimisation. It can be a suitable choice for larger ecommerce businesses with more advanced loyalty requirements.

Mage Loyalty offers a broader combination of Shopify retention features, including points, rewards, referrals, VIP tiers and wishlist functionality. Its lower-priced Starter plan also makes certain advanced loyalty capabilities accessible to businesses that may not want to begin with a $199 monthly subscription.

Ultimately, the decision depends on what a Shopify business wants from its loyalty programme. If analytics, multilingual support and established loyalty infrastructure are the priorities, LoyaltyLion deserves consideration. If combining customer engagement features, Shopify functionality and accessible pricing is more important, Mage Loyalty is worth exploring.

Before making a decision, compare the actual features included in each plan against your monthly order volume and long-term retention goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Mage Loyalty better than LoyaltyLion?

Mage Loyalty can be a better fit for Shopify businesses looking for loyalty, referrals, VIP tiers and wishlist functionality in one application. LoyaltyLion may be more suitable for brands prioritising advanced analytics, multilingual support and established loyalty management.

Does LoyaltyLion offer a free plan?

Yes. LoyaltyLion offers a free plan for stores processing up to 400 monthly orders. It includes basic points, discount rewards, branding and loyalty analytics.

How much does Mage Loyalty cost?

Mage Loyalty’s published plans start at $15 per month for Essential, $49 for Starter and $499 for Growth. Enterprise pricing is customised. Essential and Starter also have additional order-based charges above their included limits.

Does Mage Loyalty support VIP tiers?

Yes. Mage Loyalty includes VIP tiers and tiered rewards in its Starter and Growth plans.

Can I use LoyaltyLion with Shopify POS?

Yes. LoyaltyLion supports Shopify POS, with multi-location functionality available on higher plans.

Which platform is more affordable?

Mage Loyalty has a lower starting paid price, at $15 per month compared with LoyaltyLion’s $199 Classic plan. However, LoyaltyLion also has a free plan, so the most affordable option depends on the store’s order volume and required features.

Increase Repeat Orders with Retenzy

Add points, referrals, and VIP rewards to your Shopify store in under 5 minutes.

At Retenzy, we believe customer retention should be simple, effective, and growth-driven. Our team is dedicated to helping brands build stronger relationships with their customers through loyalty programs, milestones, reviews, and analytics.

Retenzy © 2026, All rights reserved.

Let’s Supercharge Your Growth Journey

Take 60 seconds to tell us about your brand. Our experts will analyze your details and contact you to craft a personalized strategy for scaling your business.

Book a Demo(Universal)