LoyaltyLion vs BON Loyalty: How the Two Shopify Loyalty Apps Differ
LoyaltyLion and BON Loyalty both offer points, rewards, referrals, VIP tiers and Shopify POS. BON Loyalty has a free plan, low-cost paid plans and VIP tiers at a set price. LoyaltyLion starts at $199 a month and adds revenue reports, lots of integrations and hands-on setup help. The right fit depends on your budget and needs.
Your store has more repeat buyers than last year. The free points widget you set up no longer feels like enough. Now you want VIP tiers, referrals that bring in new shoppers, and numbers that prove the program pays off. That is when most stores weigh up LoyaltyLion vs BON Loyalty. Both apps cover the basics well. The real gaps show up in price, plan limits and how far each app can grow with you.
Key takeaways
- BON’s paid plans cost less than LoyaltyLion’s.
- LoyaltyLion’s paid plan adds revenue reports, integrations and setup help.
- BON keeps VIP tiers for its $129 Growth plan.
- Past 500 orders a month, LoyaltyLion needs a quote.
- Test each app on mobile before you decide.
LoyaltyLion vs BON Loyalty at a Glance
| Feature | LoyaltyLion | BON Loyalty |
|---|---|---|
| Positioned for | Established brands investing in retention | Small and growing stores on a budget |
| Free plan | Yes, up to 400 monthly orders | Yes, up to 150 monthly orders |
| First paid plan | Classic, $199/month (500 orders) | Starter, about $15/month (300 orders) |
| Highest published plan | Custom quote for Advanced and Plus | Growth, about $129/month (unlimited orders) |
| Points and rewards | Yes | Yes |
| Referral program | Yes | Yes, including on the free plan |
| VIP tiers | Listed on Classic in the App Store | Growth plan |
| Birthday rewards | Available | Starter plan and above |
| Shopify POS | Classic plan | Basic plan and above |
| Languages | 7 pre-written languages on the free plan | Multi-language display on Basic and above |
| Reporting | Loyalty-attributed revenue reporting | Performance analytics on Basic and above |
| Integrations | Unlimited on Classic, 100+ available | Klaviyo and review apps on Starter, unlimited on Basic |
| Free trial | 14 days on Classic | 7 days on paid plans |
| App Store rating | 4.7 (547 reviews) | 5.0 (1,984 reviews) |
What Are LoyaltyLion and BON Loyalty?
LoyaltyLion and BON Loyalty are both Shopify loyalty apps. Shoppers earn points when they buy or take other actions. Then they trade those points for discounts and perks. LoyaltyLion is made for brands that treat loyalty as a key part of their growth. BON is made to give smaller stores a full program for a low monthly price.
LoyaltyLion
LoyaltyLion lets you reward buys, reviews, referrals and social actions. You set the rules for each one. Rewards can show at checkout, in customer accounts and on Shopify POS. It also links your loyalty data to the rest of your marketing tools.
Key LoyaltyLion features
- Points and rewards: shoppers earn points on your site and spend them on fixed or percent discounts.
- VIP tiers: top tiers can unlock perks, early access and free shipping.
- Revenue reports: the Classic plan shows how much revenue comes from loyalty.
- Integrations: Classic includes unlimited integrations. LoyaltyLion lists more than 100, including Klaviyo with ready-made loyalty emails.
- Setup help: Classic comes with onboarding and a free loyalty page design. LoyaltyLion says that design is worth $1,500.
Where LoyaltyLion stands out
LoyaltyLion makes the most sense once loyalty is a real part of your plan. Picture a fashion brand with a small marketing team. It could reward buys and reviews and run VIP tiers for its best shoppers. It could then send points data to Klaviyo and email people who haven’t spent their points. The catch is cost. Classic starts at $199 a month. Once you pass 500 orders a month, you have to ask for a quote.
BON Loyalty
BON Loyalty is a Shopify app for points, rewards and referrals. It has a free plan and three paid plans with clear prices. Each plan adds more features. A store can start with points and referrals, then add a loyalty page, POS, reports and VIP tiers as it grows.
Key BON Loyalty features
- Points and rewards: shoppers can redeem points for money off, percent off, free shipping or free products.
- Safe referrals: a referral program that blocks cheating comes with the free plan.
- Birthdays and expiry: Starter adds birthday rewards and points that expire, with email reminders.
- POS and languages: Basic adds in-store points, customer QR codes and support for more than one language.
- Extra ways to engage: Growth adds VIP and B2B tiers, points for repeat buying streaks, daily check-in points and anniversary rewards.
Where BON Loyalty stands out
BON’s main strength is the range of features at each price. Picture a growing skincare store. It could start points and referrals on the free plan. Next, it could add a loyalty page on Starter. Then it could move to Basic for POS and reports. When it wants VIP tiers, Growth adds them with no order cap. The one thing to check is whether BON’s reports and integrations will keep up as your store gets bigger.
Pricing Compared Plan by Plan
LoyaltyLion pricing
| Plan | Price | Orders Included | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Up to 400/month | Points for on-site activities, discount rewards, branding, loyalty analytics and segments, 7 languages |
| Classic | $199/month | 500/month | Loyalty page design, custom rules and rewards, unlimited integrations, onboarding, VIP tiers, POS, revenue reporting, Klaviyo flows |
| Advanced | Custom quote | Higher volumes | Adds more advanced retention and translation features |
| Plus | Custom quote | Enterprise | Adds AI-recommended rewards, advanced Klaviyo events and strategic reviews |
BON Loyalty pricing
| Plan | Price | Orders Included | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Up to 150/month | Points and rewards, anti-cheat referrals, automated emails, discount and free shipping rewards |
| Starter | About $15/month | Up to 300/month | Loyalty page, free product rewards, birthday rewards, points expiration, Klaviyo and review app integrations |
| Basic | About $29/month | Up to 500/month | Shopify POS, limited-time offers, on-site nudges, multi-language display, performance analytics, unlimited integrations |
| Growth | About $129/month | Unlimited | VIP and B2B tiers, streak and check-in points, anniversary rewards, points on product pages |
Each paid plan has a 7-day free trial. You can also pay yearly on Basic and Growth to save 7% or 20%. Big stores that need an API can ask BON about a custom plan.
What you would pay at different order volumes
The plan that fits your order count is only part of the story. Some features sit on higher plans. Even so, this table shows how far apart the two apps are as you grow.
LoyaltyLion’s free plan covers more orders than BON’s. That helps if you only need basic points. Once you need paid features, BON costs less at every level. Its Growth plan gives you VIP tiers and no order cap for about $129 a month. When you add up the real cost, count the rewards you give away too. Your loyalty program ROI depends on both.
Features Side by Side
Both apps cover the main loyalty features most Shopify stores need. The gaps are in which plan unlocks each feature and how much you can change the look. They also differ in how well they suit stores with shops or shoppers abroad.
Points and rewards
Both apps let you build a points program around buys and other actions. LoyaltyLion rewards buys, reviews, referrals and social actions with fixed or percent discounts. BON offers money off, percent off and free shipping on its free plan. Starter adds free products as rewards. Either one works well for a simple Shopify rewards program.
Referral programs
Referrals turn happy customers into a source of new ones. BON includes a referral program that blocks cheating on its free plan. That makes it an easy way to test referrals before you pay. LoyaltyLion supports referral rewards too. If referrals are key to your plans, compare the reward options and reports in each app’s demo store.
VIP tiers
A VIP rewards program keeps your best shoppers coming back. Perks unlock as they climb levels such as Silver, Gold and Platinum.
Which plan includes VIP tiers
- BON Loyalty: VIP tiers, plus B2B tiers for trade buyers, come with the Growth plan at about $129 a month.
- LoyaltyLion: the App Store lists VIP tiers on Classic at $199 a month. LoyaltyLion’s site puts them on Advanced. Check before you sign up.
Look and branding
Your loyalty program should look like part of your store. LoyaltyLion’s Classic plan includes a loyalty page made by its designers, plus rules and rewards you can change. BON adds its own loyalty page on Starter and on-site reminders on Basic. Whichever app you try, check the widget, the loyalty page and how rewards are spent on a phone.
Shopify POS and stores in more than one language
Both apps work with Shopify POS. LoyaltyLion includes POS on Classic. BON adds in-store points and customer QR codes on Basic. For shoppers abroad, LoyaltyLion’s free plan has 7 ready-made languages, with more on higher plans. BON adds support for more languages on Basic. Test that points match across online and in-store orders. Also check that your staff can explain rewards at the till.
Analytics, and Integrations
LoyaltyLion is stronger on reports and integrations. BON Loyalty has the higher App Store rating and almost four times as many reviews. Both matter, but in different ways. Reports tell you if the program works. Reviews tell you how the app behaves day to day.
Reports
A loyalty program can hand out lots of points without bringing people back more often. That is why reports matter.
LoyaltyLion reports
The free plan includes loyalty reports and customer groups. Classic adds reports on revenue that comes from loyalty. This helps a team that wants to tie loyalty to sales. Keep in mind that this revenue is not the same as extra sales the program caused. Also compare how often members and non-members buy again.
BON Loyalty reports
BON includes performance reports on Basic and above. That is a fair start for a small store. If you need deeper reports, test them in a free trial first.
Integrations
LoyaltyLion lists more than 100 integrations, including Klaviyo. Classic includes unlimited integrations and ready-made Klaviyo loyalty emails. BON links to Klaviyo and review apps from Starter. It adds unlimited integrations, including Shopify Flow, on Basic. For most stores, one question matters. Does the app send the loyalty events your email tool needs, such as points earned or a new tier?
The Main Differences in Summary
| Requirement | LoyaltyLion | BON Loyalty |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan order limit | 400 a month | 150 a month |
| Cost from 151 to 400 orders | Free | About $15 to $29 a month |
| Cost above 500 orders | Custom quote | About $129 a month |
| VIP tiers | Classic ($199) on the App Store, Advanced on LoyaltyLion’s site | Growth (about $129) |
| Revenue reporting | Loyalty-attributed revenue on Classic | Performance analytics on Basic |
| Integrations | 100+, unlimited on Classic | Unlimited on Basic |
| Setup help | Onboarding and loyalty page design on Classic | Not listed in plan details |
When you weigh up LoyaltyLion vs BON Loyalty, start with three things: your monthly orders, the features you need this year, and the tools the app must link to. Install both on a test store. Try the shopper experience on a phone. Read recent reviews from stores your size. The best Shopify loyalty app is the one that brings people back without costing more than the repeat orders it earns.
See what Retenzy costs at your order volume, with loyalty, VIP tiers and review rewards on every plan.
FAQ
Is LoyaltyLion vs BON Loyalty a fair comparison for small stores?
Yes. For small stores, the main differences are price and order limits. BON’s paid plans start at about $15 a month and include features LoyaltyLion offers on its $199 Classic plan. LoyaltyLion’s free plan covers more orders, up to 400 a month, which suits stores that only need basic points.
How much does LoyaltyLion cost?
LoyaltyLion pricing starts with a free plan for up to 400 orders a month. The Classic plan costs $199 a month and includes 500 orders. It adds VIP tiers, POS, unlimited integrations and revenue reports, with a 14-day free trial. Stores with more than 500 orders need a quote for Advanced or Plus.
Does BON Loyalty have a free plan?
Yes. BON Loyalty’s free plan covers up to 150 orders a month. It includes points and rewards, a referral program that blocks cheating, automated emails, and discount or free shipping rewards. Paid plans add a loyalty page, birthday rewards, POS, reports and VIP tiers.
How do LoyaltyLion and BON Loyalty reviews compare?
BON Loyalty has a 5.0 rating from 1,984 reviews on the Shopify App Store. LoyaltyLion has 4.7 from 547 reviews, as of November 2026. Both are well rated. Focus on recent reviews from stores that match your size and tools.
Can I switch from LoyaltyLion to BON Loyalty without losing points?
Usually, yes. Many Shopify loyalty apps let you import point balances from a CSV file. Ask the new app’s support team to help you move. Test the import on a few customers first. Then tell members about the change before you switch, so their points don’t come as a surprise.
Add points, referrals, and VIP rewards to your Shopify store in under 5 minutes.
